{"schemaVersion":1,"recordType":"legal-article","id":"law:eri:code:civil:2015:article:1509","workId":"law:eri:code:civil:2015","expressionId":"law:eri:code:civil:2015:en","title":"No compensation for Injury","number":"1509","language":"en","canonicalUrl":"https://eriatlas.com/law/civil-code-2015/article/1509/","hierarchy":{"book":"BOOK V - OBLIGATIONS","title":"TITLE I - CONTRACTS IN GENERAL","chapter":"Chapter 8. - Non-Performance","section":"Section 4. - Damages","paragraph":"Paragraph 2. - Penal Clauses"},"paragraphs":[{"id":"p1","number":"1","text":"The creditor may not demand performance of both the penalty and the obligation to which the penalty attaches.","canonicalUrl":"https://eriatlas.com/law/civil-code-2015/article/1509/#p1","sourceTargets":[{"sourceId":"civil-code-2015-en","pdfPage":425,"url":"https://eriatlas.com/sources/civil-code-2015/page/425/?article=1509&paragraph=p1#article-1509-p1"}]},{"id":"p2","number":"2","text":"That which is owed pursuant to a penalty takes the place of compensation for injury dueby law.","canonicalUrl":"https://eriatlas.com/law/civil-code-2015/article/1509/#p2","sourceTargets":[{"sourceId":"civil-code-2015-en","pdfPage":425,"url":"https://eriatlas.com/sources/civil-code-2015/page/425/?article=1509&paragraph=p2#article-1509-p2"}]},{"id":"p3","number":"3","text":"The creditor may not demand performance of the penalty where the non-performance cannot be imputed to the debtor.","canonicalUrl":"https://eriatlas.com/law/civil-code-2015/article/1509/#p3","sourceTargets":[{"sourceId":"civil-code-2015-en","pdfPage":426,"url":"https://eriatlas.com/sources/civil-code-2015/page/426/?article=1509&paragraph=p3#article-1509-p3"}]}],"caution":"This is the 2015 English-language edition attributed in its front matter to the Ministry of Justice. Eri Atlas has not independently verified the translation, later changes, or whether the text is currently in force. Nine passages are incomplete in the available scan and are identified where they occur."}